What can we learn from the old world of print, and why are LLMs bringing us back there?
Starting my career in magazines before moving across to SEO, I have noticed an incredibly full-circle moment happen. Although the explosion of AI has caused some challenges in our industry, it has also brought us back to one of the most fundamental aspects of good content — originality.
The rule of print: Opinion, facts & expertise
Flashback to 2012: the Sony PSP is still going, and people had massive DVD racks in their living rooms. I was a very green, very nervous Editorial Assistant at the time. I sent a magazine article I'd drafted up across to my Editor for review and they returned it to me with this note: “No unique angle - can we get an interview? Some stats? Research?". I packed my digital dictaphone and a notebook before heading out to secure some interviews.
Wishy washy, generalised or summarised content just wouldn't go to print. People were paying for this magazine off the shelf; the quality had to reflect that. We wanted readers not only to buy a copy, but to also subscribe with their hard-earned cash.
No matter what industry or vertical you’re in, you’ll find a passionate audience who value real substance and quality. Whether it’s vintage cars or modern coffee machines, giving your audience something worth reading that’s both insightful and original is, and always has been, rule number one in print.
The years of chasing keywords
By comparison, moving into the SEO world circa 2016 was a shock. Clients weren’t particularly keen on spending more money on content that involved interviews or proper journalistic research, and SEO best practice wasn't really advocating for it either.
Instead, we got results by producing generalised guide content, provided we included the right keywords. Somewhere along the way, we even stopped calling them ‘articles’. They became ‘copy’, which probably tells you everything about how the industry viewed content at the time. It was less about telling a great story and more about ticking the right marketing and SEO boxes.
Full circle as zero-click takes hold
In the world of LLMs and AIO, we’re seeing this on a massive scale. Platforms are already doing the summarising and generalising for us, meaning audiences often find the answers that they’re looking for without ever clicking through to a website. Articles that simply rehash existing information, without adding depth, original insight or a unique perspective, have little reason to be cited. This is where the principles of old-school print journalism come back into play, and why they matter for three key reasons:
- Citations: Building true authority through genuine experts will increase the likelihood of citation.
- Click-through: Give people something they can't get from a summary. Proprietary data, expert commentary and deeper insights create a reason to visit your site, engage with your content and share it with others.
- Audience Engagement: For all the changes in search, one thing remains the same: good content needs to connect with its audience. Whether it's Google or ChatGPT, the goal is to surface content that people find useful, interesting and worth their time. Write for your readers first, and the rest will follow.
Print is back, just not quite as we remember it. The platforms and tactics may have changed, but the fundamentals haven't. Originality is still king. Print journalism was always about creating a direct connection between writer and reader, and after taking a rather roundabout route to get here, it feels like we're finally returning to that same principle.